Welcome back, Product Bosses! Have you ever looked at your sales and thought, "I'm making money, so why does it feel like there's never enough in my bank account?" Or maybe you have shelves full of products that aren't moving, and you can't tell what to buy more of, what to stop selling, or how much inventory you actually need. In this episode, I'm joined by Catherine Erdly, retail strategist, speaker, author, and founder of The Resilient Retail Club, who spent more than 26 years in retail, including senior roles in the UK and US, before helping independent product businesses improve their sales, cash flow, and profits. Her superpower? "Give me 20 minutes looking at your data and I'll tell you why you have less money than you want."
WHY YOUR INVENTORY IS HOLDING YOUR CASH HOSTAGE
Catherine's mantra is "turnover is vanity, profit is sanity, cash is reality," and it explains why so many product businesses feel like they're being eaten alive, which is the idea behind her book, Tame Your Tiger. You bring home a cute little kitten, and one day you realize it's become a tiger that's eating everything you have. A product business is only sustainable if you make enough money every time you make a sale and you get your money back from your inventory fast enough. The first piece is your margin. That starts with your gross profit margin, the gap between what you pay for a product (including labor, even if you're making it yourself or paying family nothing) and what you sell it for. Catherine points out that big retailers have entire teams who do nothing but obsess over that number, because every expense they have is paid for by it. Then comes your actual margin: you may list a product at $20, but if everyone bought it with a 10% welcome coupon or during a 30% off sale, your real profit is different. And if your ads or promotions are eating too much of it, you have to look there too. Nothing else you do works if that foundation is shaky, and this isn't a problem only for small businesses, since I had three people in a recent mastermind running $950,000 businesses who were still figuring it out.
The second piece is your cash and your stock. Catherine's visual is a lipstick: imagine every product in your studio, warehouse, or shop is a $20 bill, then look around and tell me where your money is. Cash needs to flow out and come back in, and every week you improve your stock turn is a week of improved cash flow. A good rule of thumb is to hold about three months of stock tied to the sales you plan to make, but don't bulk up to three months if you're turning faster than that, because the game is having as little stock as possible without losing sales. This time of year is especially tricky. When 50% or more of your revenue comes in Q4, you may need credit to buy stock in advance, and Catherine shared that at the UK stationery chain Paper Chase, they held a meeting called "pushing payments past peak" to stretch supplier payments because they were hitting their credit limit ahead of Christmas. Big retailers aren't flush with cash either, which is part of why Black Friday exists. Catherine also warns about "shiny new stock syndrome," where you think you need something new to grow and forget the stock sitting in the background. One client once had four and a half years of inventory. Her advice is to go narrow and deep on your bestsellers, since 80% of your sales usually come from 20% of your range, and to only reorder true bestsellers. As she put it, if it's merely okay and it finally sells through, please don't buy it again.
The third piece is clearing dead stock without killing your brand. Catherine says the fear of damaging your brand is reasonable, because nobody wants to fall into what she calls the "Gap trap," where everything is always 40% off and nobody buys at full price. The way out is to treat clearance as a safety valve and to know that not all stock is equal. Your prime stock is doing well, so leave it alone and skip blanket discounts. Your ticking-along stock will probably sell through on its own. Out-of-season stock, what she calls "brown bananas," is hard to clear, so set it aside until the season comes back around. The bulk of your discounting should go to your slow stock, where your money is trapped. Her line from the book is "the bigger the tail, the bigger the tiger," because the more cash you have in products that aren't moving, the less you have to reinvest in your bestsellers. Make those discounts targeted, short, and specific, so you're steering customers toward the products you want to clear instead of teaching them that everything is always on sale. Timing helps too. If something didn't sell during the holidays, it's not going to pick up in the summer, so use the January sales window, when customers expect deals, to clear it. Finally, set a stock target the way big retailers do. At the end of each month, decide how much inventory you want to have, and if you're at 12 months of stock today, bring it down gradually instead of all at once.
The key takeaways I want you to remember are:
Know your margins, both theoretical and actual. Include your labor, and look at what you really sold products for after coupons, sales, and ad costs, because everything else depends on that foundation.
Treat your inventory like cash on shelves. Tie your stock to your planned sales (roughly three months as a starting point), keep it deep on your bestsellers, and only reorder products that are truly selling.
Clear slow stock with targeted, short discounts. Leave your bestsellers alone, set aside out-of-season items, and use windows like January to turn your tail back into cash without teaching customers to wait for a sale.
Product Boss, remember: you can be creative and profitable at the same time, and the business side doesn't have to feel like a tiger chasing you. If you want to clear your dead stock without hurting your brand, download Catherine's free PDF and video training at resilientretailclub.com/freebie. For done-for-you help optimizing your inventory, check out Stock Doctor, listen to her podcast, The Resilient Retail Game Plan, wherever you get your podcasts, and pick up her book, Tame Your Tiger: How to Stop Your Product Business Eating You Alive.
In This Episode, You’ll Learn:
00:00 Why making more sales doesn't always mean more money in the bank.
02:30 How Catherine turned decades of big retail experience into strategies for independent product businesses.
05:45 Why even million-dollar product businesses can struggle to make a profit.
09:00 The hidden pricing and profit margin mistakes draining your business.
11:00 How discounts, advertising costs, and overlooked expenses eat into your profits.
15:30 What big retailers know about managing cash flow during Q4.
19:00 Why inventory investments can create cash flow challenges before your biggest sales season.
21:30 How to know if you have too much inventory and money sitting on your shelves.
26:00 The inventory management mistake that keeps product businesses overstocked.
29:00 How to clear dead stock without damaging your brand.
32:30 Which products you should discount and which ones you should protect.
36:00 How to use strategic promotions to increase sales without discounting everything.
39:00 The inventory targets big retailers use to protect cash flow.
42:45 Why promoting your existing products could be more profitable than creating something new.
45:15 How one inventory strategy helped businesses grow sales with 45% less stock.
48:00 Why focusing on fewer bestsellers can help you make more money.
50:00 Where to find Catherine's resources and get help optimizing your inventory.
Resources + Links
Check out Catherine’s Podcast, The Resilient Retail Game Plan HERE!
Have inventory that's not moving? Learn how to turn slow-selling products into cash without hurting your brand with Catherine's free PDF and video training.
Want more sales with less stock? Get done-for-you help from retail pros with Stock Doctor, who run your numbers and help you optimize your inventory.
Ready to lead, run, and grow your product business beyond a million dollars, without being the bottleneck? Join me this week for a FREE workshop HERE!
Ready to stop guessing and follow a proven system? Book your strategy call HERE!
Get business tips sent right to your inbox - join the newsletter!
Follow
Jacqueline on IG: @theproductboss
